The Definitive Ranking of Every Pistol and Revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2

In the expansive and detailed world of Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2), the gun you carry says as much about you as your horse or your hat. With a myriad of pistols and revolvers at your disposal, choosing the right sidearm can be the difference between success and failure in the Wild West. But with each weapon boasting its own unique qualities, the task of selecting the perfect gun can be daunting. Fear not, partner – we've meticulously ranked every handgun from least to most impressive to help you take on any challenge that comes your way.

10. Algernon's Revolver: A Quick Draw That Lacks Punch

At the bottom of our list is Algernon's Revolver, a gun that can unleash a rapid succession of shots in the blink of an eye. However, this firearm is akin to a stunning show horse that lacks the endurance for a long ride. Its damage output leaves something to be desired, making it appropriate for situations when you're swarmed by adversaries but less ideal against tougher foes. Procuring Algernon's Revolver requires a keen eye for exotic items and a willingness to aid a flamboyant hatter on his quest for rare materials. While it may not be the most formidable weapon, it surely is a testament to your dedication and a unique addition to your arsenal.

9. LeMat Revolver: A Slow Burn With A Fiery Twist

LeMat Revolver screen of the game

The LeMat Revolver may not win any quick-draw contests, but its ace in the hole is the ability to fire shotgun shells. This versatility can be a game-changer when you find yourself out of pistol ammunition and in need of a more explosive option at close range. Its acquisition is limited to the Saint Denis gunsmith, post-Chapter Four, but for those who prefer a weapon that offers more than meets the eye, the LeMat is worth the wait.

8. M1899 Pistol: A Modern Marvel Among Revolvers

As one of the most technologically advanced firearms in the game, the M1899 Pistol brings semi-automatic firing to the table. This means a faster rate of fire, which is perfect for chaotic skirmishes. However, this modern marvel is only available in Saint Denis following a pivotal story mission, making it a late-game find. While not the top contender, the M1899 is a solid choice, especially when you're outnumbered and need to maintain a steady stream of bullets.

7. Semi-Automatic Pistol: The Little Gun That Could

Don't let its size fool you—the Semi-Automatic Pistol packs a serious punch. It's a tempest in a teapot, with a fire rate that will leave your enemies reeling and a reload speed that ensures you're never out of the fight for long. While its accuracy could be better, it shines in close-quarters combat, slicing through the opposition like a hot knife through butter. Available in Valentine and Saint Denis, this pistol is a force to be reckoned with once you've made some headway in the story.

6. Mauser Pistol: A High Capacity Crowd-Pleaser

Mauser Pistol real gun

The Mauser Pistol is akin to a well-oiled machine gun in the palm of your hand. With the highest ammo capacity of any handgun in RDR2, it's ideal for laying down a barrage of fire. However, it trades off some range and stopping power for speed, so pairing it with a more potent weapon is a strategic move. While it's locked behind story progression, you can snag one earlier if you're eagle-eyed during a key mission with Angelo Bronte.

5. Midnight Pistol: All That Glitters Is Not Gold

As the most glamorous Mauser variant, the Midnight Pistol is a testament to style over substance. While it boasts the same statistics as its standard counterpart, its lustrous finish adds a touch of class to any gunslinger's holster. Earned in a duel against the notorious Billy Midnight, this weapon is as much a trophy as it is a tool of defense.

4. Volcanic Pistol: A Slow-Firing Powerhouse

With a bark as ferocious as its bite, the Volcanic Pistol is the heavyweight champion of handguns. It deals more damage than any of its kin, making it a favorite for those who value precision and power over speed. Widely available from the get-go, this pistol is a trusty sidekick from the early chapters and remains reliable throughout your journey.

3. Calloway's Revolver: A Steady Hand in the Storm

Calloway's Revolver game screen

Calloway's Revolver is a weapon that balances style and substance. This custom Schofield is not only a feast for the eyes with its engravings and silver finish but also packs a punch in combat. Its versatility makes it an excellent choice for dual-wielding setups. To claim this prize, you must outdraw the legendary gunslinger Jim "Boy" Calloway, a feat that will earn you a revolver as famous as the man who once wielded it.

2. Otis Miller's Revolver: Gold-Plated Excellence

Almost taking the top spot is Otis Miller's Revolver, a Schofield variant that is as deadly as it is dazzling. Encased in gold and ivory, it's a weapon fit for the most discerning of outlaws. However, its beauty is matched by its rarity, as it requires a treasure hunt that's only available after the main story concludes. While it may not be the easiest to obtain, it is certainly one of the most rewarding.

1. Schofield Revolver: The Cream of the Crop

At the pinnacle of our rankings stands the Schofield Revolver. This firearm is the epitome of balance, boasting commendable damage, accuracy, and fire rate. Dual-wielding these revolvers transforms you into a veritable force of nature, capable of handling any challenge the West throws your way. Its early availability makes it an essential pick-up, ensuring that you're well-equipped from the earlier chapters of your adventure.

As we've seen, each pistol and revolver in RDR2 has its own niche, offering a range of options that cater to various playstyles and scenarios. Whether you prefer the rapid-fire of a Semi-Automatic or the deliberate power of a Volcanic Pistol, the choice is yours. Remember, a gunslinger is only as good as the steel they carry, so choose wisely and may your aim be true.

Now that we've ranked every pistol and revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2, you're better equipped to navigate the treacherous paths of the Wild West. While some guns may shine brighter than others, don't forget that every weapon has its moment. It's the gunslinger's skill, cunning, and quick thinking that truly makes the difference. So saddle up, arm yourself, and carve out your legend under the western sky.